◇◇新语丝(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys1.dyndns.org)(xys.3322.org)◇◇

科学院院士候选人吉林大学刘式墉教授涉嫌抄袭论文

SIOM

下面是一篇发表在 Journal of Crystal Growth 179 (1997) 328-329 上的指证
文章：

Comment on 'Characterization of InxGal_xAs/InP epilayers
by X-ray double crystal rocking curve peak profile analysis by Haiyan 
An(a), Ming Li(b), Shuren Yang(a), Zhenhong Mai(b), Shiyong Liu(a)'[J. 
Crystal Growth 148 (1995) 31][1]

抄袭文章作者地址：
a Department of Electronics Engineering, Jilin University, Number 79, 
JieFang Road, Changchun 130023, People's Republic of China
b Institute of Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, P.O. Box 603, 
Beijing 100080, People's Republic of China

下面是文章第一段及其中文大意：

作者声称“我们推广了Kato的统计理论到外延层衍射。。。”实际给出的结果确
在五年前被发表[2，3]。作者文章[1]显示其公式，参数，及方程是出自[2,3]， 
然而， 作者却将其作为原创结果发表。而且，多层系统，包括外延层，异质结，
超晶格，的衍射统计理论已在[4]中有详细论述。

the authors assert that "we
generalized Kato's statistical theory to the diffrac-
tion of epitaxial layers....". The actually given the-
ory was published five years ago [2, 3]. Indicated in
[1] are the formulations, parameters and equations
borrowed from [2, 3]; however, the authors [1]
publish them as original results. Moreover, the
statistical theory of a diffraction on multilayer sys-
tems, including epitaxial layers, heterostructures
and superlattice is considered in detail in [4].

引文：
[1] H. An, M. Li, S. Yang, Z. Mai, S. Liu, J. Crystal Growth
148 (1995) 31.
[2] V.I. Punegov, A.P. Petrakov, N.A. Tikhonov, Phys. Status
Solidi (a) 122 (1990) 449.
[3] V.I. Punegov, Soy. Phys. Cryst. 35 (1990) 336.
[4] V.I. Punegov, Phys. Status Solidi (a) 136 (1993) 9.

LB评：

不仅抄袭，还耍障眼法， 

“The authors of the paper [1] start from consid-
eration of a general field of atom displacement
u = (u) + 8u (1)
and refer to work [5]. However such a representa-
tion in paper [5] is not present. ”

实际上文章拼拼凑凑，整个被 “comment" 得体无完肤。
“Also, is not clear why the authors [1] take into
consideration a model of a mosaic crystal. A similar
rocking curve peak profile is possible to obtain by
use of many defect models [8]. ”

这样的院士候选人. 又是学生的错吧。

(XYS20030706)

◇◇新语丝(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys1.dyndns.org)(xys.3322.org)◇◇