送交者: skipper3 于 2005-8-11, 22:54:12:
回答: 别的我敢说，但是国进民退是张维迎的一贯观点 由 特立独行 于 2005-8-11, 22:03:12:
1. Confusing morality with ethics(as usual). I say Zhang's morality is totally irrelevant to whether he is right or wrong. Taking money from Greencool while speaking in favor of the company maybe unethical, but only maybe. I say as long as he didn't lie or didn't intentionally conceal truth there is no ethical problem.
2. LiKe way of thinking when tackling a WenKe problem(as usual too). Negative result from one experiemnt, in this case Greencool, does not prove that Zhang's theorem is fundamentally incorrect.
So I say 王石川 is crap. he does not know what the issue really is nor does he know how to argue.