Alan Turing on mechanical explanation of analogy


所有跟贴·加跟贴·新语丝读书论坛

送交者: 短江学者 于 2016-03-16, 17:04:26:

Alan Turing on analogy in an interview on October 27, 1949 : ``I think you could make a machine spot an analogy, in fact it's quite a good instance of how a machine could be made to do some of those things that one usually regards as essentially a human monopoly. Suppose that someone was trying to explain the double negative to me, for instance, that when something isn't not green it must be green, and he couldn't quite get it across. He might say 'Well, it's like crossing the road. You cross it, and then you cross it again, and you're back where you started.' This remark might just clinch it. This is one of the things one would like to work with machines, and I think it would be likely to happen with them. I imagine that the way analogy works in our brains is something like this. When two or more sets of ideas have the same pattern of logical connections, the brain may very likely economise parts by using some of them twice over, to remember the logical connections both in the one case and in the other. One must suppose that some part of my brain was used twice over in this way, once for the idea of double negation and once for crossing the road, there and back. I am really supposed to know about both these things but can't get what it is the man is driving at, so long as he is talking about all those dreary nots and not-nots. Somehow it doesn't get through to the right part of the brain. But as soon as he says his piece about crossing the road it gets through to the right part, but by a different route. If there is one such purely mechanical explanation of how this argument by analogy goes on in the brain, one could make a digital computer do the same."



所有跟贴:


加跟贴

笔名: 密码: 注册笔名请按这里

标题:

内容: (BBCode使用说明