送交者: gordon 于 2005-5-26, 12:17:30:
回答: 讲和谐，讲逻辑。 由 Latino2 于 2005-5-25, 13:06:21:
It's pleasant to have an argument with sb who really talks with logic.
Yeah, it's easy to say "”中国发展的症结，就是制度！“ but will you contradict this statement? Only saying that is an easy conclusion does not mean that statement is wrong. If you want to disaprove it, or give specifics, that will be welcome.
With peasants take the majority of Chinese population, their condition really mirrors China's development. With even the Communist party de-emphasizing GDP growth, and emphasizing "people-based ..." "homonious society" , I really cant understand what you mean by "China is developing rapidly".After all, the enviorment has been deteriorating, and social conflicts are mounting (that is part of the Li Changping's speech).
Guizhou is only a starting example(even it can be an extreme example) to initiate his speech, and what he lists actually applies to China as a whole(because those are systems). Then if this is the case, then his conclusion (only too obvious again), Chinese peasants are so poor and mierable, will surely stand. The fact that peasants in Zhejiang are better off (only materially, and relatively) doesnt disprove the general condition for Chinese peasants, just as the fact that there is a single millionair(or even billionair,or even many of them)wont contradict the general conclusion.