送交者: mangolasi 于 2006-2-24, 10:03:37:
回答: 坚决反对"从人名看北大"一文 由 F107 于 2006-2-24, 09:37:28:
it and found it's indeed terrible.
That's not a problem of '打击面'. It's terrible even it only targets a small minority. It's the philosophy of heired superiority that shocks (to begin with, Mr.Fang is also from humble origin rather than from a 书香门第, either. And he is roughly in the same enviornment of those 'army', 'great', 'eleven'. So can we also say that Mr.Fang is 专业知识有了一点，读书人的风范品德操守气度，既没有从
家里承继，也不能在社会得到熏陶?)
BTW, even when members of the 'upper class' is teasing the 'lower class', it's usually in a very subtle way. This article is indeed of bad taste. I can see no 读书人的风范品德操守气度 from it.
Alas, I hope the author has never lived in a western country and formed some feeling the idea of social mobility. If this is not the case, I have to conclude his/her experience in the western civilization had been entirely wasted.